Reviewers of Qubahan Journal of Coaching and Sports Sciences (QJCS) should evaluate manuscripts objectively, constructively, independently, and confidentially.

1. Relevance and Scope

Assess whether the manuscript:

  • Fits QJCS's Aims and Scope
  • Addresses a relevant coaching or sports-science topic
  • Makes a meaningful contribution

2. Originality

Assess whether:

  • The research question is meaningful
  • The contribution is clearly identified
  • The manuscript provides new evidence, interpretation, methodology, or theoretical insight

3. Literature

Assess whether:

  • Relevant scholarship is discussed
  • The research gap is clear
  • The conceptual framework is suitable
  • References are relevant and credible

4. Methodology

Assess:

  • Study design
  • Sample or participants
  • Procedures
  • Measurements
  • Statistical methods
  • Ethical requirements

5. Results

Assess whether:

  • Results are clearly presented
  • Analyses support the findings
  • Tables and figures are appropriate
  • Claims are evidence-based

6. Discussion

Assess whether:

  • Findings are appropriately interpreted
  • Results are compared with existing literature
  • Alternative explanations are considered
  • Implications are appropriate

7. Conclusion and Limitations

Assess whether:

  • Conclusions follow from evidence
  • Limitations are acknowledged
  • Recommendations are justified

8. Research Integrity

Report concerns involving:

  • Plagiarism
  • Duplicate publication
  • Fabricated data
  • Manipulated data or images
  • Unethical research
  • Fabricated references
  • Citation manipulation
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest

9. Recommendation

Provide a clear recommendation supported by scholarly reasoning.

Reviewer comments should remain respectful, specific, constructive, and evidence-based.