Review Guidelines
Reviewers of Qubahan Journal of Coaching and Sports Sciences (QJCS) should evaluate manuscripts objectively, constructively, independently, and confidentially.
1. Relevance and Scope
Assess whether the manuscript:
- Fits QJCS's Aims and Scope
- Addresses a relevant coaching or sports-science topic
- Makes a meaningful contribution
2. Originality
Assess whether:
- The research question is meaningful
- The contribution is clearly identified
- The manuscript provides new evidence, interpretation, methodology, or theoretical insight
3. Literature
Assess whether:
- Relevant scholarship is discussed
- The research gap is clear
- The conceptual framework is suitable
- References are relevant and credible
4. Methodology
Assess:
- Study design
- Sample or participants
- Procedures
- Measurements
- Statistical methods
- Ethical requirements
5. Results
Assess whether:
- Results are clearly presented
- Analyses support the findings
- Tables and figures are appropriate
- Claims are evidence-based
6. Discussion
Assess whether:
- Findings are appropriately interpreted
- Results are compared with existing literature
- Alternative explanations are considered
- Implications are appropriate
7. Conclusion and Limitations
Assess whether:
- Conclusions follow from evidence
- Limitations are acknowledged
- Recommendations are justified
8. Research Integrity
Report concerns involving:
- Plagiarism
- Duplicate publication
- Fabricated data
- Manipulated data or images
- Unethical research
- Fabricated references
- Citation manipulation
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest
9. Recommendation
Provide a clear recommendation supported by scholarly reasoning.
Reviewer comments should remain respectful, specific, constructive, and evidence-based.