QJCS follows a structured editorial workflow designed to maintain scholarly quality, research integrity, editorial independence, and consistency of the published record.

STAGE 1 — SUBMISSION

Authors submit manuscripts through the journal's Open Journal Systems platform.

STAGE 2 — ADMINISTRATIVE AND TECHNICAL SCREENING

The Editorial Office checks:

  • Manuscript completeness
  • Author information
  • Formatting
  • Required declarations
  • Supporting files
  • Compliance with submission requirements

STAGE 3 — EDITORIAL SCREENING

An academic editor evaluates:

  • Relevance to the Aims and Scope
  • Scholarly quality
  • Originality
  • Clarity of contribution
  • Methodological adequacy
  • Research-integrity concerns
  • Suitability for external review

STAGE 4 — RESEARCH-INTEGRITY SCREENING

Where appropriate, submissions may undergo:

  • Similarity assessment
  • Ethics approval verification
  • Informed-consent verification
  • Conflict-of-interest review
  • Funding-disclosure review
  • Authorship checks
  • Image or data integrity checks

STAGE 5 — DOUBLE-ANONYMOUS PEER REVIEW

Manuscripts progressing to review are normally evaluated by at least two independent reviewers.

Author identities are concealed from reviewers and reviewer identities are concealed from authors.

STAGE 6 — EDITORIAL DECISION

Possible decisions include:

  • Accept
  • Minor Revision
  • Major Revision
  • Resubmit for Review
  • Reject

STAGE 7 — REVISION

Authors submit a revised manuscript and point-by-point response.

STAGE 8 — FINAL DECISION

The Editor-in-Chief or delegated academic editor makes the final decision.

STAGE 9 — PRODUCTION

Copyediting → Layout → Proofreading → Metadata Verification → Final Quality Control

STAGE 10 — PUBLICATION

The Version of Record is published with complete metadata, DOI, licence information, volume and issue details, and full text.